The Perfect Comps – Part 1

Story code: ST-001648

Part 1: Erasing the Past

The nail gave way with a sickening crunch of drywall, bringing Marcus’s framed Bronze Star down into his palms. He didn’t pause to dust off the glass. He shoved the shadowbox into a plastic tote bin, right on top of his grandfather’s folded burial flag, and grabbed the next frame. His wife’s radiant smile from their anniversary trip to Jamaica vanished into the dark plastic, immediately replaced by an eight-by-ten thrift-store frame containing a stock photo of a blonde woman and a golden retriever. Across the living room, Dave paced in front of the bay window, clearing his throat and adjusting the collar of his polo shirt. Dave held an invisible coffee mug, gave a stiff wave to the empty street, and practiced a booming, relaxed greeting. He sounded like a man who owned a boat. He sounded like he belonged in this house more than Marcus did.

Marcus moved to the mantel. He swept the graduation photos of his kids into a cardboard box. He took down the carved wooden masks his mother had brought back from Ghana. He scrubbed the walls of his own existence with frantic, mechanical efficiency. Every bare spot left behind felt like a bruise on the house they had spent five years turning into a home. He handed Dave a stack of generic landscape paintings bought at a discount outlet, gesturing for him to hang them over the faded rectangles on the paint. Dave took them with a grim nod, stepping up to the hearth to cover the last traces of Marcus’s family. Dave muttered under his breath, rehearsing a monologue about property taxes and the local school district. The words bounced off the bare walls, making the living room feel hollow, stripped of its soul in under an hour.

The kitchen was next. Marcus grabbed a trash bag and swept all the magnets off the refrigerator. The kids’ finger paintings, the graduation announcements from cousins, the magnetic calendar from the local AME church all tumbled into the black plastic. He wiped down the stainless steel until not a single fingerprint remained. He replaced his collection of hot sauces and cast-iron skillets with a pristine, unused espresso machine Dave had brought over from his own apartment. Dave walked in, placing a pair of brand-new golf shoes by the back door for optimal visibility. Dave looked around the kitchen, his eyes darting to a small framed prayer on the wall above the sink. Marcus didn’t wait for Dave to point it out. He ripped the frame down and tossed it into the bag. He was erasing thirty-eight years of a hard-fought life, scrubbing away his service, his heritage, and his family, just to make his own home palatable to a stranger. He wiped the sweat from his forehead with the back of a dusty forearm, feeling the strange emptiness of the kitchen island. They had staged it perfectly. It looked like a model home. It looked like Marcus had never existed.

Dave checked his watch, the heavy silver dive watch he had worn specifically for this charade, and tapped the glass. Marcus nodded, moving into the hallway to do a final sweep. A stray deployment photo sat on the console table, tucked behind a decorative bowl. Marcus snatched it, feeling the sharp corner of the frame bite into his palm. He sprinted toward the living room, searching for the tote bin, but Dave had already hauled it to the garage. A heavy, rhythmic chime echoed through the house. The doorbell. Dave froze in the center of the living room, his face draining of color. He looked at the front door, then back at Marcus, completely forgetting the relaxed homeowner persona he had spent the last hour practicing. The chime rang again, louder this time, echoing off the bare walls. Marcus looked down at the deployment photo in his hand. He dropped it to the floor and kicked it violently under the deep shadow of the sectional sofa, hearing it slide against the hardwood until it hit the wall.

Marcus grabbed a plastic spackle knife from a canvas tool bag resting on the floor. He dipped it into a tub of joint compound, smearing a thick white streak down the leg of his old jeans. He rubbed a handful of the white dust into his palms and slapped it onto his T-shirt. Dave took a deep breath, puffed out his chest, and marched toward the entryway with heavy, confident steps. Marcus dropped to his knees beside the baseboards, scraping the clean metal blade against the pristine drywall. He kept his head down, staring at the floorboards, shrinking into the background as nothing more than a hired pair of hands. The deadbolt clicked open, letting in a rush of humid afternoon air and the heavy footsteps of the man holding the clipboard. Dave launched into his booming greeting, extending a hand to welcome the stranger into a life that was not his.

The nail gave way with a sickening crunch of drywall, bringing Marcus’s framed Bronze Star down into his palms. He didn’t pause to dust off the glass. He shoved the shadowbox into a plastic tote bin, right on top of his grandfather’s folded burial flag, and grabbed the next frame. His wife’s radiant smile from their anniversary trip to Jamaica vanished into the dark plastic, immediately replaced by an eight-by-ten thrift-store frame containing a stock photo of a blonde woman and a golden retriever. Across the living room, Dave paced in front of the bay window, clearing his throat and adjusting the collar of his polo shirt. Dave held an invisible coffee mug, gave a stiff wave to the empty street, and practiced a booming, relaxed greeting. He sounded like a man who owned a boat. He sounded like he belonged in this house more than Marcus did.

Marcus moved to the mantel. He swept the graduation photos of his kids into a cardboard box. He took down the carved wooden masks his mother had brought back from Ghana. He scrubbed the walls of his own existence with frantic, mechanical efficiency. Every bare spot left behind felt like a bruise on the house they had spent five years turning into a home. He handed Dave a stack of generic landscape paintings bought at a discount outlet, gesturing for him to hang them over the faded rectangles on the paint. Dave took them with a grim nod, stepping up to the hearth to cover the last traces of Marcus’s family. Dave muttered under his breath, rehearsing a monologue about property taxes and the local school district. The words bounced off the bare walls, making the living room feel hollow, stripped of its soul in under an hour.

The kitchen was next. Marcus grabbed a trash bag and swept all the magnets off the refrigerator. The kids’ finger paintings, the graduation announcements from cousins, the magnetic calendar from the local AME church all tumbled into the black plastic. He wiped down the stainless steel until not a single fingerprint remained. He replaced his collection of hot sauces and cast-iron skillets with a pristine, unused espresso machine Dave had brought over from his own apartment. Dave walked in, placing a pair of brand-new golf shoes by the back door for optimal visibility. Dave looked around the kitchen, his eyes darting to a small framed prayer on the wall above the sink. Marcus didn’t wait for Dave to point it out. He ripped the frame down and tossed it into the bag. He was erasing thirty-eight years of a hard-fought life, scrubbing away his service, his heritage, and his family, just to make his own home palatable to a stranger. He wiped the sweat from his forehead with the back of a dusty forearm, feeling the strange emptiness of the kitchen island. They had staged it perfectly. It looked like a model home. It looked like Marcus had never existed.

Dave checked his watch, the heavy silver dive watch he had worn specifically for this charade, and tapped the glass. Marcus nodded, moving into the hallway to do a final sweep. A stray deployment photo sat on the console table, tucked behind a decorative bowl. Marcus snatched it, feeling the sharp corner of the frame bite into his palm. He sprinted toward the living room, searching for the tote bin, but Dave had already hauled it to the garage. A heavy, rhythmic chime echoed through the house. The doorbell. Dave froze in the center of the living room, his face draining of color. He looked at the front door, then back at Marcus, completely forgetting the relaxed homeowner persona he had spent the last hour practicing. The chime rang again, louder this time, echoing off the bare walls. Marcus looked down at the deployment photo in his hand. He dropped it to the floor and kicked it violently under the deep shadow of the sectional sofa, hearing it slide against the hardwood until it hit the wall.

Marcus grabbed a plastic spackle knife from a canvas tool bag resting on the floor. He dipped it into a tub of joint compound, smearing a thick white streak down the leg of his old jeans. He rubbed a handful of the white dust into his palms and slapped it onto his T-shirt. Dave took a deep breath, puffed out his chest, and marched toward the entryway with heavy, confident steps. Marcus dropped to his knees beside the baseboards, scraping the clean metal blade against the pristine drywall. He kept his head down, staring at the floorboards, shrinking into the background as nothing more than a hired pair of hands. The deadbolt clicked open, letting in a rush of humid afternoon air and the heavy footsteps of the man holding the clipboard. Dave launched into his booming greeting, extending a hand to welcome the stranger into a life that was not his.


Leave a Comment